Predatory Journals and Conferences
Lists of "good" and "bad" journals and conferences are highly sought after because they are easy for researchers to use. However, they are often controversial. Why?
As predatory practices evolve, the lists are difficult to keep up-to-date; referring to or relying on outdated versions may harm researchers. In addition, the list of "bad" journals is controversial as it is difficult to verify. As for the list of "good" journals, the selection criteria can be subjective. Thus, it is not easy to come up with a list that has widespread agreement. New journals, for example, may not be listed in the top 25% journals of high impact factor, but it does not mean they are bad.
The most effective way to avoid predatory journals and conferences is to improve one's understanding of predatory practices. Therefore, PPRI provide checklists and tools for distinguishing predatory journals and conferences from those that are non-predatory, based on the report of the Combatting Predatory Academic Journals and Conferences (2022) published by the InterAcademy Partnership (IAP).
1. Watch out! Ways to Distinguish Predatory Journals and Conferences
We recommend becoming familiar with the spectrum of predatory behaviors of journals and conferences (Figures 1 and 2). It is harder and harder to define and clearly distinguish predatory from reputable publishing. Moreover, a binary classification of "good" and "bad" journals does not accurately reflect the diversity and complexity of the issue. The spectrum approach helps reduce the chance of being preyed upon and avoid other improper practices.
Figure 1: A spectrum of predatory behaviours for journals
Figure 2: A spectrum of predatory behaviours for conferences
2. Checklists and Tools
Other than the list of predatory practices, checklists can also be useful. Think.Check.Submit and Think.Check.Attend are two widely used checklists to understand if a journal or a conference is predatory or not. Both are free of charge and are available in nearly 40 languages. In addition, the IAP and PPRI provide resources as shown below:
3. What Should you do if you submit a paper to a predatory journal?
The Ottawa Hospital Research Institute's (OHRI) Centre for Journalology is a leading organization on predatory publishing in the field of health and biomedicine. Its website includes many resources and provides helpful suggestions on what to do when researchers believe they have submitted their paper to a predatory journal (See Figure 3).
Figure 3: What to do if you submit to a predatory journal?
Taken from the Centre of Journalology website (ohri.ca)
※ This work is copyright of the InterAcademy Partnership (IAP) and is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International. The full report (in English) can be found at https://www.interacademies.org/publication/predatory-practices-report-English.
